Episode 47
Improving Mental Health with Neuromodulation
Watch Now
Listen Now
Podcast: Play in new window
Description
In this episode we are joined by Dr. Ashley Johnson, DO to discuss depression and improving mental health with neuromodulation.
Talking Points
- Reviewing current terms related to modern science such as neuroplasticity and neuromodulation.
- Discussing treatments for depression and other mental health disorders that induce neuromodulation and help repair damages in the brain.
- Considering treatment options that could be possible in the future.
Quotes
“What we don’t understand we tend to stigmatize, and what we stigmatize we tend to make illegal. ”
Episode Transcripts
—
empathy is knowing your own darkness
without that connection you don’t have
anything what’s the opposite of
addiction just freedom
hello and welcome to another episode of
finding peeks i’m jason friesma your
host this week joining me
is uh peaks recovery center’s chief
medical officer
dr ashley johnson and peaks chief
clinical officer
jason friesman
chief operations officer
yeah all right straight to the blooper
reel here we go um
but anyway uh
we are here to continue a conversation
with dr johnson um
and kind of the innovative approaches
she is taking in her in her practice and
and uh where i kind of want to start is
i know last week you introduced a
metaphor around a frayed rope and so if
you could maybe do a quick summary of
that in case some people are tuning into
this episode that didn’t watch the last
one and then uh and we’ll kind of go
from there okay sure
uh so last week we had we just talked
about it’s a
helpful analogy
kind of to to summarize the effect of
ketamine really all of the
neuromodulatory
treatments that was kind of the word
that we’ve lumped these treatments into
so basically just meaning we modulate
nerves
meaning we change nerves
or improve them is the hope and so
the analogy of the frayed rope
uh
helps people understand
that uh if it’s like taking a rope like
a hemp rope that’s got a lot of fibers
uh kind of braided together and twisted
together and
so
when you take something rough like a
brick maybe maybe even like a razor
blade or something and you rub it across
it it just frays the rope
in that area
and
we liken that to untreated mental health
conditions
to include chronic pain
uh and substance use disorders and so
when all of those conditions
kind of go untreated for years in most
cases um
it’s it’s like it’s fraying the ropes of
our brain so the ropes are are
synonymous with nerves so nerves are
typically long and um they’re just
elongated and like a rope is and so
when all these
kind of neurotransmitters and hormones
are
are dysregulated in our body over time
that’s usually how the ptsd or the major
depression is manifesting internally
it’s fraying the ropes of your brain and
so when we
what we found is that we have to
intervene in that process in order to
stop that process of just
destruction to the nerves
we have
over time found many different types of
treatments that work
to stop that process but then go a step
further and do what we call neuro
regeneration so meaning it helps rebuild
the nerves but it also helps
like clinton mentioned is like the the
medications the therapies
the tms
is like pouring wax on the nerve and so
it’s almost like it’s trying to help
heal it
um
not so much like a band-aid
but
to where it takes it a step further and
actually neuro regenerates and it
smooths out that rope
in a sense
and while they all of these treatments
that we talked about
ketamine infusion spravato which is s
ketamine nasal spray transcranial
magnetic stimulation which is tms
psychotherapy that targets all these
different disorders
all of them are kind of working in the
same way and also to include psychiatric
medications
in that they’re stopping the assaultive
process on our brains and then they’re
helping us to move forward and
regenerate
okay
and i wanted to talk just for a minute
specifically about tms i had the
privilege of helping you i think
hone in your machine and you put a cap
on me
and turn the dial up to 11 out of 10 and
give me a little
shot of magnets
but i’d love for you to explain it in a
way that isn’t uh so colloquial
and yeah
it’s a good way yeah we’ll understand
that yeah so um maybe we should get a
clip for this podcast absolutely yeah
[Laughter]
so what we do with uh
the machine that i use in my clinic
is
manufactured by brainsway and so
i mentioned that not to advertise for
them necessarily but because they have
patented their type of device where they
utilize a helmet so they are the only
tms
device manufacturer that utilizes a
helmet to deliver these
magnetic pulses essentially into
the brain and different areas of the
brain that correspond with some
different conditions that people suffer
from
and
all of the other types of devices out
there are what we call figure eight
devices for the most part those are all
the ones that are
on the market primarily and are fda
approved for major depressive disorder
treatment
and actually more specifically treatment
resistant major depressive disorder or
trd treatment resistant depression so
that’s kind of the new
um or terminology emerging terminology
right that that that will become
standard or is becoming standard and so
um
with
tms when it’s administered through
a helmet
we have you come and sit in a chair much
like the one you’re sitting in it’s got
a straight back
it’s not reclined
but we place the helmet we deliver a few
pulses
to to try to locate different areas of
your brain and specifically
the area
of the motor cortex which is the outer
layer of the brain is what cortex is
and motor refers to muscle and so
when we find that motor cortex by
delivering a few pulses here and there
it will
we’ll focus on
for major depression having your fingers
twitch like that and then we know okay
look we found the motor cortex if we can
get your fingers to twitch it doesn’t
hurt
unless you turn it up yeah
and the goal is to treat at the lowest
intensity possible
just
for my own
clarification the process of finding the
cortex or the motor cortex is that the
brain mapping piece that you talk about
yes is that what that’s referring to
exactly thank you that that is the term
for
the first session that you
you attend for to start tms is
essentially the intake
um and so it’s where we are learning the
most about your brain specifically
because everyone’s brain is very
different and has
nuances as to where maybe
neurons are crossing and that kind of
thing and so we have to do kind of like
a test sure
to
identify where your specific
in the case of major depression your
specific left prefrontal cortex is
and so that is what we are looking for
so that when we
place the helmet then for the treatment
session
um that is where
the it’s about right here on your brain
uh that’s where the left prefrontal
cortex is and so this helmet is is
guiding all of these magnetic forces
right here into the left prefrontal
cortex and so
that will
pulse
thousands of pulses over about a
kind of the standard for how long it
takes to go through a tms session
for major depression we now have a very
accessible um
improved
time frame that we can administer the
same treatment
with about the same efficacy meaning
this this you get the same effect pretty
much from it in three minutes
so we’ve now come over time from
week
for six weeks
to now three minutes a day
um and so that’s that’s been pretty
groundbreaking as well that’s called the
theta burst
and you may see that on websites and
such for different clinics that
administer tms they’ll call it theta
burst stimulation and uh
tbs is the way that it’s being
abbreviated now so all of this
terminology is just emerging and
becoming standard so
um
but that that frees people up a great
deal in their lives because as you can
imagine six weeks of coming into a
clinic five days a week
can be pretty cumbersome for your life
if you’re trying to work try to raise
your family trying to go to school
that kind of thing and so now that we
have a three minute
treatment session
that has
made it a little more accessible for
people so with tms the beauty of it
is that you can still go back to work
sure back to school in the same day go
back home you can drive yourself
there are no restrictions in that regard
for the most part unless you have some
very obvious
side effects which is extremely rare
so as far as being invasive it would be
would it be considered a non-invasive
considered non-invasive exactly
and the fda has approved tms now for
first was for
treatment resistant depression
trd
and
and then was ocd
with
a few select devices not all devices are
approved
to treat ocd
the brainsway device with the helmet is
approved for that specifically
and it that’s somewhat important for
people to understand because that way if
they do suffer from debilitating ocd and
they need to get tms for it
because medications are notorious for
not
um fully treating ocd
they need to look for a clinic that has
the ocd specific
tms device
they’re not all the same
and so
that that’s one way that you can look
for that
um
well i think that’s important to
identify that not all tms is the same
that not all tms devices are the same
and that um different devices will be
more efficacious for different diagnoses
and
so it’s a it’s a really i think that we
start using state you know
tms and it becomes a sort of generalized
idea or concept but the reality is that
tms is a really diverse within it within
the treatment itself is really diverse
in approach and
yeah so i think that’s really
interesting it is absolutely and there’s
more
you know every year it seems like
there’s more
uh movement and what type of devices are
coming onto the market
to treat different conditions like
migraines right now there’s
a tms like device
delivers the same type of magnetic
pulses but you hold it up behind your
head
to treat basically to abort a migraine
interesting um just with a few pulses
and you can have it at home and so you
can see that you know there’s this whole
spectrum and evolution of tms that i
think we’ll see quickly come out um as
they’re doing more studies on it how to
maybe deliver different protocols
through the day and that kind of thing
kind of like the evolution of the
computer right it starts off and it
takes up this entire room right now and
and now it’s right here on this table
exactly over time yeah exactly it’s
really interesting
so it
i find this to be so interesting and i
and it’s an emerging field and then i’m
a
counselor so i uh
my knowledge of it is very limited um
other than you know what i can read
online and everything but i i did wonder
just from your perspective i i had found
um an article talking about ketamine
um and it studied people who just got
ketamine and then people who received
ketamine and therapy and then people
received just therapy and then people
who received neither and far and away
the most efficacious
intervention
um
for depression was the was the ketamine
and therapy piece and and how do you how
do you see those
how do you see these new modalities uh
that you’re talking about um
modulating modalities i can’t remember
what the term was but uh neuromuscular
modulation yeah the neuromodulation uh
interventions how do you see that
being enhanced by clinical interventions
from from a counseling perspective
so right now i think we are very early
in this process
the protocols are still being developed
and refined
through
you know our major institutions right
now
as far as ketamine assisted therapy
goes
there are
lots of therapists out there who are
working hard at helping develop these
protocols
and and i think the reason you’re
hearing so much about it is because
they’re seeing such
improved outcomes especially in ptsd
um
and while i i don’t know that
it they’re going to be you know
complicated protocols that we’ll find i
think what we see is
is we’re really applying our principles
of therapy and the various different
modalities
um cognitive behavioral therapy
prolonged exposure um
to basically while someone’s under the
influence of ketamine
that that kind of opens up
their mind sure so that you can help
rework the memories
and
uh i’ve seen it quite a bit to where
i’ve even attempted it myself and
as a psychiatrist and in my office where
someone is is really going through the
ketamine infusion
really for more the nerve repair aspect
of it
and because we know it has a very rapid
immediate anti-depressant effect
but you can see
how pliable their mind becomes
interesting while they’re going through
the infusion and so you actually feel
especially a seasoned therapist
you actually feel a lot of confidence
that
wow we’ve got some amazing access yeah
some real space
memories yes their pain their um
you know how they’ve been experiencing
their grief um to where you can start
applying if you’ve you know in most
cases been able to build some rapport
with this patient by gathering their
history their
psychosocial history specifically
understanding diagnostically why do they
suffer from what they suffer from so
that you can then if you are present
while they’re going through the ketamine
infusion you can then intervene
in the discussion with them
they are way you know for the most part
i think
most patients that i’ve treated in this
realm
they are very willing to discuss
and as long as they feel safe that
you’re there
occasionally you know they’ll they’ll
feel like some weird dissociative
effects because it’s a dissociative
anesthetic but there are ways to kind of
comfort someone help give them tips on
you know just kind of put your hand on
the seat
sometimes they’ll feel like maybe the
bottom the floor is falling out from
under them not quickly but it’s kind of
like an odd
sensation that they might feel um
but there’s there’s some very good ways
that you can address that while you’re
talking with them
constantly reassuring them that you’re
with them who you are
um
where they are
and how much they’re they’re being
supported and that it’s a safe place to
discuss their yeah their trauma
basically it’s so interesting to think
about dissociation i mean when we talk
about it in clinical terms and generally
speaking i mean
it’s not a positive or a um it’s a
firming word or
experience for people but to think to to
use a dissociate a level of dissociation
that it makes that kind of unlocks all
of these doors that otherwise could take
i don’t know years to unlock i mean we
work uh i mean therapists can work for
months and months and months to try to
get act like you said sort of this this
access to the mind and in the way that
um
what what seems that ketamine gives us
almost instant access to through this
kind of dissociative moment associative
properties
and the another beautiful part of it is
that ketamine is so short acting
that you recover ex very quickly right
so what we typically do is we’ll have
someone
complete the infusion within about 40
minutes
and then they have about 20 minutes of
recovery time and then they’re usually
able to walk out the door
uh they can’t drive sure but
they’re able to usually safely go home
with with someone um whom they trust
um get through the evening sleep it off
and then uh the goal is to see the
antidepressant effect continue sure or
maybe in in the case of ptsd maybe see
the edge come off of the hyper vigilance
the avoidance behaviors and all of those
uh hallmark symptoms that you typically
see with ptsd maybe the intrusive
memories aren’t as intense as well so
absolutely it’s really exciting to see
that happen i have also seen it with ocd
to where people are
they feel free to become more productive
like in their job
they are less obsessing about you know
whatever it is that that they’re
obsessive about whether it’s body image
um
whether it’s it’s about you know i’m i’m
not doing this right
that kind of thing and then the
compulsions that usually follow
oftentimes we’ll just ease off
that’s pretty amazing do you have any
indication if people can remember
the experience like if
somebody does a therapeutic intervention
during the infusion or right after do
they remember it
they do some okay
i um
i think most patients that i’ve treated
with ketamine
remember most of the time okay that
they’re in the room
i actually noticed though that the parts
that they don’t remember
are insignificant
and actually good because it was the
times where maybe they felt like
where am i you know i don’t sure i don’t
know what’s going on here am i outside
of my body i mean that can be common
maybe they see the walls start to wave
that’s that’s common too
they don’t remember that typically
speaking and if you can comfort them
through it and reassure them that this
is normal let’s keep going they’re
usually um going to do fine
interesting
and then
where do you see this all headed we were
talking before the show that
um
all of your training experience with
with this modality has been since
you got out of med school so you’ve had
to teach yourself or access whatever
resources were out there to learn this
stuff but
where’s this headed i mean i think about
um psilocybin or um
lsd micro dosing these are kind of some
popular things right now i mean
psilocybin isn’t
uh criminalized in denver anymore and
and so i know people are kind of drawn
to that or where
yeah where do you see this emerging
with other
i think there is a uh
a rush to regulate now that makes sense
and
that’s what i am seeing i’m hearing
about reading about i know they’re
studying psilocybin in boulder
um
[Laughter]
unbrand
but i also was just reading this week
how
you know all the ivy league schools the
major medical institutions
there
are quickly trying to form a psychedelic
psycho
psychedelic psychiatry residency or
fellowship basically so that
like i went through a general adult
psychiatry residency right that’s four
years um well there’s many different
ways that you can then sub-specialize in
child and adolescent psychiatry sleep
medicine
or um
you know geriatric psychiatry those kind
of
um
specializations and now they’re trying
to add
psychedelics like interesting psychiatry
i still have to think about how to say
it yeah that is going to be tough
yes um so that because you can feel it’s
like this wave coming off
all of this uh momentum
to
kind of like the gold rush of
trying to find out how do we do this
safely right
because like we were talking about
before it
most of these treatments all really kind
of emerged around the same time or at
least
re-emerged lsd is a
absolutely
you know decades ago they were studying
it
um
it just didn’t quite go anywhere um
and now i think ketamine is being lumped
into the psychedelics and
interesting so i think it’s been kind of
it’s you know as far as i have seen it
it’s been kind of the trailblazer here
and so now psilocybin follows and lsd
and
mdma
exactly started in the 80s really so
exactly and so i don’t know maybe we
have more resources now to study it more
thoroughly
and safely that’s my hope um is why when
it seems like
i mean most of those drugs were
scheduled on drugs were they sure no
medical use and so
i mean you’d be punished way more for
having mushrooms than say heroin which
is a schedule two i believe if i
remember right but like i just find it
really interesting
they’re likely that war on drugs and
scheduling the drugs in that way uh
create that
um despair or put so many barriers to
researching this because it was
basically saying social stigma and on
its own i mean i think that it’s you
know there was
uh what we don’t understand we tend to
stigmatize right and then what we
stigmatize we tend to make it legal so
right now and then hopefully in the end
that regulation or over regulation maybe
of it stigmatization
as well we can find the balance
and i think for instance with ketamine i
think that’s you know it’s a schedule
too yeah yeah and uh
i think
necessarily so sure um in that it does
help keep it controlled
um
you know in in most cases except in like
this like we were talking about the
online companies that maybe it’s it’s
just easier to access oral ketamine
with some access to maybe an online
therapist as well so
seemingly that that is fairly
unregulated it’s just difficult to tell
and
also as we talked about
you know i’ve had i’ve worked with many
patients who have
felt as if that was such an unregulated
approach
to utilizing ketamine
that they actually suffered from it in
that
it kind of got them on a anxiety mood
roller coaster and that they would they
were taking ketamine as needed
which many drugs are prescribed that way
uh but the effect that they got from the
ketamine
was not what they anticipated right yeah
we’re not looking at full efficacy in
that in that manner so exactly
yeah i think it’s i’m it’s interesting
that all of these sort of new uh
approaches kind of surfaced around the
same time right like we see this sort of
like i don’t know as the second maybe
third wave of psychiatric intervention
approaches especially to mental health
um
and i’m curious what you’re i’m just
kind of from my own curiosity what what
do you think propagated that you know
like what do you think kind of initiated
or sort of started moving us into this
direction into this new wave of
psychiatry or this next wave of
psychiatry
i think uh
i think we just got tired of
or maybe stagnant’s a better word sure
of the medications
not
achieving more than
you know maybe 30 percent efficacy uh in
treating the vast majority of these
disorders that we’ve talked about
um
[Music]
and so
you know as
necessity is the mother of invention
right and so
uh i think
necessity can be equated to people
suffering really is that is what’s
driven us to keep looking is
you know i think we always had these
clues
uh in the neurologic
realm
of how the brain was working and
overlapping with
the psychiatric
conditions
so neurologic and psychiatric processes
very much overlap to include pain
and
in substance use
that
the fields have kind of converged some
and so that’s where i think tms is a
great example of that
and that’s been in development since
insurances to start covering it so right
on time yeah there we go
well i would like to
uh come out on this show as a former
employee of a big pharma company i used
to sell pharmaceuticals
and i think part of my answer to your
question is like pharmaceutical
companies
want people on medications they take
every day for the next two years
when i hear about these treatment
episodes of
tms or ketamine it’s very short and so
there isn’t
a ton of money to make for big pharma
and these are medications that aren’t
really regulated by big pharma at least
right now until they come up with
different formulations like spravata but
like i think
i think it’s interesting that uh
i i feel like psychiatry is moving away
from its reliance on big pharma and kind
of carving their own path now that’s my
weird that’s my
outsiders and as a psychiatrist that’s
very freeing yeah i’m sure
up until the last few years i i mean i
have felt like i am completely dependent
on
finding a medication that can help in
some way
and that almost no matter what whoever
comes to me
is expecting to be prescribed something
and so it’s nice to now be able to offer
different treatments that
they don’t feel like they will they have
to be reliant on it
now it doesn’t it it doesn’t necessarily
change
the trajectory for some people who have
chronic conditions they may have to stay
on their medications the rest of their
lives
but they may not have to
uh be only partially treated right
partially improved and that’s what the
vast majority of people i think have had
to suffer through
up until we’ve started finding these new
newer treatments
well when we talk about disrupting an
industry right at peaks and i think that
this is it’s great to see psychiatry as
a field have these sort of avenues of
disruption where we do get to see
innovation come forward and we and we
recognize that suffering has not gone
away nor will it ever but we can do a
better job as far as addressing it
especially
the
levels and types of suffering that are
debilitating for people and chronic and
really um really disrupt their lives in
a way that is um
really uh tragic
yeah and unmanageable for sure
i i have one more unscripted question i
might have more uh
um do you see a lane for cannabis in
this and if not why not because like we
we’re here in colorado
i mean we could probably see some
dispensaries from where we sit like i
is there a lane for cannabis because
that’s all the popular thing right is
and we also treat cannabis use disorder
yeah as part of our yeah in our clinics
and certainly at some levels it
exacerbates a lot of mental health
issues but i’m wondering if there’s a
lane for it as a medicine too i’m
curious
i think there will be okay i think we’re
trying to get there
uh again it’s kind of like this just
ever-evolving process to regulate sure
the dosing of thc
um
you know now we understand a little bit
more about cbd and
how it’s not psychoactive and that kind
of thing and it can treat some of the
things that marijuana in particular we
were relying on to try to treat um like
insomnia or pain or
even ptsd which there are no
you know if you if you rely on the fda
to put out these indications
cannabis is not approved for anything
sure
by the fda
and i i am passionate about letting
people know it’s absolutely not
indicated for ptsd for major depression
for really any psychiatric
uh condition
but the word on the street is that it is
and you can act you know you can find
justification pretty much anywhere
online um
if you want for literally anything right
and so there is a lot to be found out
there
of
um
people and companies and institutions
trying to justify it but none of it has
ever been
proven safe
and effective to treat those specific
conditions
because guaranteed the va would be
you know
advocating for that for ptsd if it were
if the studies were there and the
evidence was there that it was well
treated that way
and so i think
cannabis in particular
is going to
follow a different path because we know
so much about it and its side effects
now whether or not people believe the
side effects
because of this legalization process i
think maybe it can cloud that
somewhat is that that gives people a
false sense of security is that oh well
it’s legal it must be safe
it’s kind of like with alcohol right is
yeah it’s legal
but it’s not safe yeah absolutely um
and it depends on the level of use when
do you start using it
and actually now that i’m saying this
out loud it’s kind of
very similar to the trajectory of
alcohol use in someone’s life if they
start as a child
drinking alcohol that it’s probably
indicative of the problems they’re going
to have later in life
or as a teenager
we know that if if you start drinking
regularly at age 15
or earlier
you have a much much higher risk of
developing alcoholism or alcohol use
disorder
you know within the next decade of your
life pretty much and
similarities could be discussed about
cannabis in that
uh we know that
if you start using cannabis in your
teens
adolescents in general and regularly you
have about a 15
percent chance of
developing schizophrenia from it
meaning permanent psychosis it never
goes away
and it could be a low level of it
i’ve seen it in many people where they
just kind of carry around a low level of
paranoia
they just constantly have to do reality
checking and
[Music]
but it is disruptive in their life and
so usually you can go back and you can
take a history to find that they started
using cannabis very early in life
usually in early high school or middle
school and
and just continued from there and so
and if you have an underlying genetic
predisposition for a psychotic disorder
or a mood disorder like bipolar you are
a much higher risk of just opening that
box
through cannabis use
and a lot of people just don’t realize
that they don’t understand it
we’ve also found
some very good evidence that
people who have used cannabis off and on
since adolescence
if they
continue to use it in their
later decades of life
starting in their 40s 50s and 60s
if they’re using it consistently then
even if they’ve taken a break from it
like in their 20s and 30s potentially
and then they go back to regular use of
cannabis the cognitive decline is
very significant
and in that age group specifically and
um whereas
if someone who has never touched
cannabis
or rarely
up until their
they have a much less
they have a lesser chance of having that
significant of a cognitive decline
uh
in those age groups so
there’s just there is a lot to consider
there’s so many caveats to to that
question it sounds like yeah yeah there
are
the difference of course with alcohol is
like alcohol is a licorice you get it
from the liquor store
these dispensaries put you know little
green crosses and act like
yeah there’s a medical
reason and justification that it’s
somehow
um
safe or approved or whatever and i think
that that’s
i mean unlike the other
medications we were talking about
earlier and interventions like tms
marijuana is much more ready shoot aim
we’re like we’ve already shot it now
we’re trying to aim it
right uh probably the wrong order there
um
so i
we are at it out of time and i just hit
my mic um
i really i really appreciate you coming
in and joining us i this i think is a
really exciting
direction that we’re headed and and i
think um you know having been in this
field a long time and like i said even
worked in the pharmaceutical field it is
refreshing to think about something
other than
um you know a lifetime of a medication
cocktail that constantly needs
adjustment and all that but if there
could be things that either augment the
medications or even can help people come
off of them or whatever to to treat
mental health illness i think that’d be
great so
with that we will sign off um
thank you all for tuning in i i hope you
enjoyed the discussion i certainly did
please follow us on facebook and
we have a tick tock account which is
weird and then
[Laughter]
and then
instagram and all those other things but
uh
thank you and
—